FrictionPaste your draft

Teardown

Maker's Schedule, Manager's Schedule

Paul Graham, paulgraham.com, July 2009. One of the most shared essays in software — and still a draft with a lede problem. Read the way Friction reads any draft: structure first, commas later.

Predicted readers still here across the essay's 17 paragraphs. The cliff sits at paragraph 11, the essay's longest paragraph — a detour into office-hours machinery — and the most quotable line arrives at 6, then gets buried under 11 paragraphs of aftermath.

Friction predicts that 100 percent of readers start this essay, that the share falls gently through the first 10 paragraphs to 76 percent, then drops sharply to 58 percent at paragraph 11 — the essay's longest paragraph, a detour into office-hours machinery — and then drifts down to 45 percent by the end. All numbers are predicted, not measured.

Note 1 of 3

The payoff is in paragraph 6, and it is one line long

“Having a meeting is like throwing an exception” is the essay everyone remembers — the line that gets quoted back at every meeting-heavy team. It arrives at paragraph 6 of 17, and the 11 paragraphs after it never top it. I’d give that line the title and the lede.

Note 2 of 3

The essay is a definition when the reader came for a story

The first 8 paragraphs are a taxonomy — two schedules, defined, contrasted, restated. But the material comes alive when it turns into story: the 3 am shift in paragraph 12, the “grab coffee” trap in 13 to 15. The genre can’t decide whether it is an explanation or a how-to.

Note 3 of 3

The cliff at paragraph 11 is a 142-word detour

“Office hours” is where the story stops for machinery: the essay’s longest paragraph, all signup programs and scheduling mechanics. I predict readers leave here. Moving it after paragraph 16 would keep the argument whole and let the essay earn its detour.

Reader proof

None here, and I won't invent a chart. This page carries no Beacon, so there's nothing measured to put next to the prediction. On a writer's own published post, the predicted map sits beside where readers actually quit.

Another one: read a teardown of Joel Spolsky's Things You Should Never Do, Part I.

Would it say that about your draft?

Paste your draft. Your first one is free.

Paste your draft